Explore our review of Mickey Reece’s unconventional horror-drama, Agnes (2021). Delve into its unique two-part structure, powerful performances, and profound themes of faith, loss, and the aftermath of trauma. Not your typical possession film. Includes full movie details, summary, and official trailer.
Civil War (2024) – Movie Details and Full Review
Introduction
In the landscape of modern horror, where tropes often feel recycled and predictable, Mickey Reece’s Agnes (2021) emerges as a genuinely singular and audacious film. Marketed initially as a demonic possession horror, Agnes quickly reveals itself to be something far more ambitious and deeply unsettling: a two-part narrative that pivots dramatically from supernatural terror to a poignant, character-driven drama about loss, faith, and the long shadow of trauma. Reece, known for his idiosyncratic filmmaking style, subverts expectations with a boldness that will either captivate or frustrate, but undeniably leaves a lasting impression. It’s a film that asks profound questions, not just about demons, but about the very human struggles that often manifest in the guise of the supernatural.
Movie Details
- Title: Agnes
- Release Date: December 10, 2021 (USA)
- Genre(s): Horror, Drama
- Director: Mickey Reece
- Writers: Mickey Reece, John Selvidge
- Main Cast:
- Molly C. Quinn as Sister Mary
- Jake Horowitz as Benjamin
- Ben Hall as Father Donaghue
- Mary Buss as Mother Superior
- Hayley McFarland as Sister Agnes
- Chris Browning as Father Black
- Sean Gunn as Paul Satchimo
- Production Companies: Divide / Conquer, QWGmire, XYZ Films
- Distributor: Magnet Releasing
Synopsis (Spoiler-Free)
Rumors of demonic possession plague a secluded Catholic convent, prompting the church to send the cynical, disgraced Father Donaghue (Ben Hall) and his young, earnest neophyte Benjamin (Jake Horowitz) to investigate. They find Sister Agnes (Hayley McFarland) exhibiting terrifying signs of demonic infestation. The first half of the film delves into the unsettling atmosphere within the convent and the attempts to perform an exorcism on Agnes. However, just as the traditional horror narrative seems to be reaching its crescendo, Agnes takes a radical turn, shifting its focus entirely to Sister Mary (Molly C. Quinn), a close friend of Agnes, years after the events at the convent. Mary, now living outside the church, grapples with the profound spiritual and emotional fallout of what she witnessed, attempting to rebuild a life in a world that feels both mundane and alien after her extraordinary experiences.
Movie Review
Agnes is a film of two distinct halves, a bold structural choice that defines its unique character. The first half meticulously builds a tense, claustrophobic atmosphere within the convent walls. Reece employs a minimalist, almost theatrical approach, relying heavily on stark lighting, unsettling sound design, and the raw performances of the ensemble. Hayley McFarland as the titular Agnes delivers a genuinely terrifying performance, embodying the grotesque and unpredictable nature of demonic possession. The scenes of her outbursts are chilling, visceral, and uncomfortably real, amplified by the unsettling sound design that makes every guttural scream and crack of bone resonate. Ben Hall’s Father Donaghue is a weary, disillusioned priest, whose skepticism provides a compelling counterpoint to the escalating chaos.
However, it’s the film’s audacious pivot that truly distinguishes it. Approximately halfway through, Agnes abandons its horror façade almost entirely, fast-forwarding years into the future to follow Sister Mary. This dramatic shift is jarring, intentionally so, and might alienate viewers expecting a straightforward horror film. Yet, for those willing to embrace its experimental nature, this second half becomes the film’s beating heart. It’s a quiet, introspective drama that explores the devastating psychological and spiritual toll of trauma, the complexities of lost faith, and the struggle to find meaning in a seemingly ordinary life after extraordinary events.
Molly C. Quinn delivers an exceptional, understated performance as Sister Mary. Her portrayal is one of profound sadness and quiet desperation. We witness her navigating mundane jobs, awkward social interactions, and a deep-seated spiritual void. The film explores her attempts to reconnect with a sense of purpose and belonging, often through unconventional means, while the specter of her past experiences subtly looms. This second half cleverly reframes the “horror” from overt supernatural threats to the more insidious and enduring horrors of internal struggle, emotional isolation, and the aftermath of a broken belief system.
Reece’s direction is consistently unconventional. He favors static shots, often allowing scenes to play out in long takes, emphasizing dialogue and character interaction over frenetic editing. The humor, when it appears, is dark, dry, and often comes from unexpected places, adding another layer of eccentricity to the film’s tapestry. The narrative remains ambiguous in parts, leaving certain questions unanswered, which further contributes to its thought-provoking nature. Agnes isn’t interested in spoon-feeding its audience; it invites contemplation and discussion.
Summary
Agnes is a challenging but ultimately rewarding cinematic experience. It begins as a gripping, if unconventional, exorcism film, but transforms into a poignant character study of a woman grappling with the aftermath of spiritual and personal upheaval. While its abrupt structural shift may not appeal to all, it is precisely this bold choice that makes Agnes stand out. Bolstered by compelling performances, particularly from Molly C. Quinn and Hayley McFarland, and Mickey Reece’s distinct directorial vision, Agnes is a unique blend of horror and drama that offers a raw, humanistic look at the enduring questions of faith, doubt, and resilience. It’s a film that defies easy categorization and deserves to be seen by those looking for something genuinely different.
Explained: The Discomfort of the Aftermath and the Nature of Faith
The most striking and discussed aspect of Agnes is its radical structural shift. By effectively splitting the film into two distinct genres – horror and then character drama – Mickey Reece deliberately confronts audience expectations. This isn’t a flaw; it’s a thematic statement. The first half gives us the visceral, chaotic horror of possession, something audiences are familiar with. But then, Reece asks: what happens after the demon is (perhaps) expelled? What is the human cost of such an ordeal, not just for the possessed, but for those who witness and are deeply affected by it?
The film suggests that the real horror isn’t just the manifestation of evil, but the emptiness and loss of faith that can follow. Sister Mary’s journey in the second half is a powerful exploration of spiritual desolation. Her life outside the convent is devoid of the certainty and community she once knew. The film subtly hints that the “demons” might not be external entities as much as manifestations of deep-seated trauma, unresolved grief (Mary’s past loss of a child is central), and the crushing weight of institutional dogma.
The ambiguity around whether Agnes was truly possessed, or simply manifesting extreme psychological distress within the confines of a rigid religious system, adds to the film’s depth. Father Donaghue’s skepticism in the first half hints at this, and Mary’s subsequent struggles reinforce the idea that perhaps the greatest battles are fought within the mind and soul, long after the pyrotechnics of an “exorcism” have faded. Agnes ultimately becomes a profound meditation on how we cope when our foundational beliefs are shattered and the search for meaning in a world that offers no easy answers.
Official Trailer Link
Now, let’s move on to the next movie review : The Exorcism of God.
