A movie score is not a verdict. It is the output of a method, and each major site uses a different one. An 85% on Rotten Tomatoes and an 8.5 on IMDb do not mean the same thing, and a film can look great on one and average on another without anyone being wrong.
This guide explains what IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, Letterboxd and CinemaScore actually measure, why critics and audiences disagree, and a simple five-step routine for choosing a movie you will enjoy. It stays useful as films come and go, because it is about how to read scores, not about any single title.
The short answer
- Rotten Tomatoes tells you how many critics liked a film, not how much they liked it.
- Metacritic gives a weighted average of critic scores, so it shows how strongly critics felt.
- IMDb and Letterboxd show what a large audience of viewers thinks.
- CinemaScore captures how people felt on opening night.
- No single number decides it. Compare a critic score, an audience score and the written reviews before you press play or buy a ticket.
How each rating system works
The table compares the five scores you meet most often. The “watch out for” column is the part most viewers miss.
| Score | Who rates | Scale | What it tells you | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer | Approved professional critics | Percentage of positive reviews | How widely critics approved. 60% and above is Fresh; below 60% is Rotten. | A mild “it was fine” and a rave both count as one positive review. |
| Rotten Tomatoes Audience Score (Popcornmeter) | Viewers | Percentage of positive ratings | How many viewers liked it. | Can be pushed by organised campaigns, especially on new releases. |
| Metacritic Metascore | Selected critics and publications | 0 to 100, weighted average | How strongly critics liked it. Movies are green at 61 to 100, yellow at 40 to 60, red at 0 to 39. | Some critics count more than others, and the weights are not published. |
| IMDb rating | Registered users | 1 to 10, whole numbers | What a very large audience thinks. | It is a weighted average, not a simple mean, and the exact formula is kept secret to resist vote manipulation. |
| Letterboxd rating | Members, often keen film fans | 0.5 to 5 stars, in half-star steps | What committed movie lovers think. | Members skew towards cinephiles, so mainstream crowd-pleasers can score lower than you expect. |
| CinemaScore | Audiences polled on opening night | Letter grade | How the first paying audience felt right after watching. | Measures reaction on day one, not how a film holds up over time. |
Rotten Tomatoes: a percentage of approval, not a grade
The Tomatometer is the percentage of professional critic reviews that are positive. Every review is sorted into fresh or rotten, so a lukewarm review and a glowing one count the same. A film becomes Fresh at 60% and above. “Certified Fresh” is a stricter badge that needs a score of 75% or more plus minimum review counts and a consistent score over time.
Metacritic: a weighted average of critic scores
Metacritic converts each review to a number from 0 to 100 and then takes a weighted average, giving more weight to some critics and publications. Because it keeps the strength of each opinion, it separates “liked” from “loved” better than a percentage can. Movies with a Metascore of 81 or higher that have enough reviews earn the “Must-See” label.
IMDb and Letterboxd: the audience view
IMDb users rate from 1 to 10, and Letterboxd members rate from half a star to five stars. Both show crowd opinion, which is useful for answering “will people like this?” It is less useful for answering “is this well made?”
A simple example of why the numbers differ
Imagine a film where 90 of 100 critics give a modest 6 out of 10. The Tomatometer would show 90%, because almost every review is positive. Metacritic would show a score near 60, because the average review is only decent. Both numbers are correct. They answer different questions. The example is hypothetical, but this gap is exactly why a high Tomatometer does not always mean a great film.
Why critics and audiences often disagree
Critics and audiences are usually asking different questions. A critic has watched thousands of films and judges originality, craft and ambition. A viewer on a Friday night wants to be entertained, moved or scared, and a film can deliver that well without being innovative.
Three patterns explain most big gaps:
- Genre fans rate generously. Horror, action and franchise films often score higher with their core audience than with critics.
- Slow or experimental films split the crowd. Critics may admire the ambition, while general viewers find the pace hard and score it low.
- Expectations change the score. A film sold as a masterpiece gets marked down when it is merely good, and a modest surprise gets marked up.
A large gap is not a warning sign. It is a clue. Ask which group you are closer to, and read a few reviews from that side.
A five-step routine for choosing a movie
- Check one critic score and one audience score. For example, Metacritic plus IMDb or Letterboxd. If both are strong, the film is a safe pick.
- Look at how many ratings there are. A score built on a few dozen votes or reviews can swing a lot. Hundreds of critic reviews or tens of thousands of user votes are far more stable.
- Read the gap. If critics and audiences disagree, decide which side matches your taste.
- Read two or three written reviews, one positive and one negative. The reasons matter more than the number. A complaint about pacing may not bother you at all.
- Match the film to your mood. A 7.0 comedy can be the right choice on a tired evening, and an 8.3 slow drama can be the wrong one.
If you use this routine for a month, you will learn which critics and which score types match your taste. That is worth more than any single rating.
Red flags: when a score should not be trusted
- Very few ratings. A brand-new release with a handful of votes can show a perfect or terrible number that will not last.
- A sudden, extreme swing. If a film drops or jumps in a day, check whether the change comes from organised voting rather than real viewers. Sites use countermeasures against this, but they are not perfect.
- A score that ignores your taste. A 9.0 horror film is a poor pick if you dislike horror.
- Only one source. A single site can be gamed or skewed by its audience. Two or three sources are much harder to fool.
- Scores from before release. Early festival or social-media reactions often come from a friendly audience. Wait for the wider release.
How to read a written review
A number tells you how much. A written review tells you why. When you read one, look for:
- Specific reasons. “The second half drags because the plot repeats” is useful. “It was boring” is not.
- What the reviewer compares it to. A film judged against its genre is more useful than one judged against an unfair standard.
- Spoiler discipline. A good review explains your experience without telling you the story.
- A clear recommendation for a type of viewer. “Great for fans of slow thrillers” helps you decide in seconds.
This is the standard we hold ourselves to on Movies Reviews Hub: every review explains the reasons behind the score and who the film is for.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good IMDb rating?
As a rule of thumb, 7.0 and above is generally good and 8.0 and above is exceptional. Always compare within a genre and check how many votes the score is based on.
Is Rotten Tomatoes or Metacritic better?
Neither is better. Rotten Tomatoes shows how many critics approved of a film, while Metacritic shows how strongly they liked it. Using both together gives a fuller picture.
What does Certified Fresh mean?
It is a stricter badge on Rotten Tomatoes. A film needs a Tomatometer score of 75% or higher, a minimum number of critic reviews, and a score that stays consistent over time.
Why is a movie I love rated low?
Ratings reflect an average of many tastes. A film can be wonderful for a specific audience and still score modestly overall, especially if it is slow, strange or aimed at a niche.
Are movie ratings reliable?
They are reliable as a guide and unreliable as a verdict. Use them to shortlist films, then read a few written reviews to decide.
Final thoughts
Treat a rating as the start of your decision, not the end. Check one critic score, one audience score and the number of ratings, then read the reasons. Browse our Movie Reviews and Top Lists to put this routine to work on your next watch.
Sources
The rating-system facts in this guide come from the sites’ own help pages:
- Rotten Tomatoes: Tomatometer and Certified Fresh criteria
- Metacritic: how the Metascore is created
- IMDb Help: weighted average ratings
Rating methods and thresholds can change, so check each site’s help page if you rely on an exact number.